The what-the-hell effect: why one slip turns into a binge, and how to stop it

The what-the-hell effect is the tendency to give up on a goal completely after one small slip: "I already broke my diet, so I might as well eat everything." Psychologists Janet Polivy and Peter Herman documented it in dieters, and the fix is less guilt and looser rules, not more willpower.

Updated: 2026-11-21 · ibigcall

What the what-the-hell effect is

You set a rule: no sugar, no phone after 11, no spending this week. Then you break it once, in a small way. Logically one cookie is one cookie. But the reaction many people have is different: the day is ruined anyway, so the rule is off until tomorrow, or Monday, or next month.

Janet Polivy, a University of Toronto psychologist who has studied dieters since the 1970s, and her longtime co-author C. Peter Herman gave this reaction its blunt name. In a 2020 paper they describe the dieter's reasoning like this: "what the hell, my diet is already broken so I might as well eat and enjoy for now." In the technical literature the same pattern is called counterregulation or the disinhibition effect.

The milkshake study that started it

The finding goes back to a 1975 experiment by Herman and D. Mack, published in the Journal of Personality. Normal-weight participants were split into two groups: those who habitually restricted what they ate ("high restraint") and those who did not. Under the cover story of a taste test, they were first given a "preload," which in the standard description of the study was zero, one or two milkshakes, and then asked to sample ice cream and eat as much as they liked.

The people who were not dieting behaved the way you would expect: the more milkshake they had drunk, the less ice cream they ate. The restrained eaters did the opposite. Their intake went up with the size of the preload. Having been made to break their diet, they ate more, not less.

It is about the rule, not the calories

Later studies showed that the trigger is the belief that the diet is broken, not what is actually in the stomach.

In a 2010 study by Polivy, Herman and Deo, 106 young women were each served the same standard slice of pizza and then asked to rate cookies, eating as many as they wanted. Some of them saw their slice next to another person's that was a third smaller, which made their own look big. Non-dieters who thought they had the big slice ate fewer cookies afterward. Dieters ate significantly more. The pizza was identical for everyone; only the impression of having overeaten differed. "The diet is wrecked, but it wasn't their fault," Polivy told the University of Toronto's magazine, adding that dieters seemed quietly pleased to get the larger portion.

The same 2020 review describes research in which restrained eaters overate after a preload only when the food was one they considered forbidden, regardless of its calories. Any amount of a banned food, the authors write, "may be too much for one's diet to tolerate." They also list other things that knock restraint loose: emotional upset, alcohol, and being distracted or mentally overloaded.

Why one slip snowballs

Put the findings together and the mechanism is fairly clear:

  • The goal is a line, not a quantity. "No sweets today" has only two states, kept and broken. Once it is broken, the second cookie costs nothing extra on the scoreboard.
  • The reset is in the future. If the rule restarts tomorrow, the rest of today is a free zone.
  • Guilt asks for comfort. A slip feels bad, and the quickest relief available is usually the very thing you were avoiding.
  • Self-control is already tired. Stress, drink and distraction are exactly the conditions under which the slip happened in the first place.

Addiction researchers describe a close cousin, the abstinence violation effect, where a single lapse is read as proof of a permanent flaw and turns into a full relapse. We cover that in our guide on how to track bad habits.

It is not only about food

The research above was done on eating, mostly in labs and mostly with young women, so be careful about stretching it. Still, the reasoning is easy to recognize elsewhere:

  • "I already went over budget, so I may as well order the other thing too."
  • "I missed Monday's workout, the week is shot."
  • "I have had one cigarette, so I am a smoker again."
  • "I lost my 40-day streak, there is no point in starting from zero."

Streak counters make this worse. A streak turns months of effort into one fragile number, and when it resets, the display says you are back where you started, which is false.

How to recover after a slip

1. Go easier on yourself (this one has evidence)

In a 2007 experiment by Adams and Leary, college women ate an unhealthy preload, and some were then prompted to think about their eating with self-compassion instead of self-criticism. Among highly restrictive eaters, that prompt reduced distress and reduced how much they ate afterward. Something similar showed up with procrastination: in a study of 134 first-year students, those who forgave themselves for putting off revision before a first exam procrastinated less before the next one. That study was correlational, so treat it as a hint rather than proof. But both point in the same direction: beating yourself up feeds the spiral, and letting it go starves it.

2. Shrink the unit of failure

Do not write off the day. The next decision is a new one. "I had the cookie; the next thing I eat is dinner" keeps the damage at one cookie.

3. Replace bright lines with budgets

"Dessert twice a week" survives a slip; "no sugar ever" does not. A rule with room in it gives you nothing to shatter. The Polivy and Herman findings on forbidden foods suggest that the ban itself is part of what sets the binge off.

4. Decide the after-slip rule in advance

Write it down while you are calm: "If I break the rule, I log it and carry on as normal at the next meal." A plan made beforehand beats a negotiation with yourself at 11 pm.

5. Count slips, not streaks

Three slips this week against seven last week is progress, even though every one of them reset a streak. Look at the trend over weeks.

6. Notice when it happens

If slips cluster late in the evening, after drinks or after bad days, the useful change is to the situation, not to your character.

A caution: if eating regularly feels out of control, or restriction and bingeing are taking over your life, that is beyond self-help tips. Talk to a doctor or a therapist who works with eating disorders.

A tracker that expects you to slip

The tools that hold up best are the ones that assume a slip will happen. Our app Sin Tracker is a tongue-in-cheek take on that idea. You log each of the seven deadly sins on a calendar in two taps, so a bad day is a few marks rather than a zeroed counter. Repent the next day and the sin counts for half, and once a month you get an indulgence to spend. Vows are short on purpose, seven or fourteen days, and the stats show your worst hour and worst day so you can see the pattern. The app answers every entry with a sarcastic one-liner, because a joke is a better reply to a slip than "what the hell." It is satire, not therapy.

Frequently asked questions

What is the what-the-hell effect in psychology?

It is the tendency to abandon a goal entirely after a small violation, reasoning that the damage is already done. Psychologists Janet Polivy and Peter Herman described it in dieters, who ate more, not less, after being made to break their diet.

Who discovered the what-the-hell effect?

The underlying finding comes from a 1975 study by Peter Herman and D. Mack, in which restrained eaters ate more ice cream after a milkshake preload. Herman and Janet Polivy developed the research and gave the effect its informal name.

How do you stop the what-the-hell effect?

Treat a slip as one event, not a ruined day. Respond with self-compassion instead of guilt, use flexible limits instead of total bans, decide in advance what you will do after a lapse, and track the number of slips over time, not only streaks.

Is the what-the-hell effect the same as the abstinence violation effect?

They are closely related. The abstinence violation effect comes from Marlatt's work on addiction relapse, the what-the-hell effect from research on dieting. Both describe one lapse turning into giving up because of how the person interprets it.

Does breaking a streak undo my progress?

No. A streak is only one way of counting. The days you already put in still happened, and the frequency of slips over several weeks is a more honest measure of change than the current streak length.

Sources

  1. Polivy J, Herman CP (2020). Overeating in Restrained and Unrestrained Eaters. Frontiers in Nutrition 7:30
  2. Herman CP, Mack D (1975). Restrained and unrestrained eating. Journal of Personality 43(4):647-660 - PubMed
  3. Does Dieting Affect How You Think? - University of Toronto Magazine (on Polivy, Herman & Deo, 2010)
  4. Adams CE, Leary MR (2007). Promoting self-compassionate attitudes toward eating among restrictive and guilty eaters - Scholars@Duke
  5. A cure for procrastination: forgive yourself - BPS Research Digest (Wohl, Pychyl & Bennett, 2010)