Shaggy dog stories and anti-jokes: what they are and why they work

A shaggy dog story is a long, rambling joke that builds toward a big payoff and deliberately ends in an anticlimax, such as a pointless punchline. An anti-joke does the same thing in one or two lines: it sets up a joke and then gives a flat, literal answer. In both, the missing punchline is the joke.

Updated: 2026-11-21 · ibigcall

What a shaggy dog story is

A shaggy dog story is a joke that breaks the basic contract of joke-telling on purpose. Normally a setup earns its length: the longer you listen, the bigger the payoff. A shaggy dog story piles up detail, side plots and suspense, and then ends with something small, silly or beside the point. Dictionaries describe it as a long, rambling joke that ends in a deliberate anticlimax. The laugh, when it comes, is partly a groan: you realize the teller has held your attention for five minutes for no reason at all, and that this was the plan.

The form has a few reliable ingredients:

  • Length. The story takes far longer than its ending deserves.
  • Irrelevant detail. Names, places, numbers and digressions that never matter.
  • A straight face. The teller acts as if all of it is building to something.
  • An anticlimax. A flat remark, a dreadful pun, a single sound, or no ending at all.

Where the name comes from

The name comes from a joke about an actual shaggy dog, and nobody agrees on which version came first. In the one recorded by the lexicographer Eric Partridge, a wealthy London family on Park Lane loses a valuable, very shaggy dog and advertises for it. An American finds a dog that matches, carries it across the Atlantic and presents it at the door, where the butler takes one look and says, "But not so shaggy as that, sir!" In another version, from the Morris Dictionary of Word and Phrase Origins, a newspaper competition searches for the shaggiest dog in the world, and when the winner is finally presented to the aristocrat who sponsored the contest, he says, "I don't think he's so shaggy." The philosopher Ted Cohen gives a third in his 1999 book Jokes: a boy's dog wins shagginess contests at every level up to the world championship, where the judges decide the dog is not that shaggy.

The label itself is from the 1930s. The earliest known use in print is by J. C. Furnas in Esquire in May 1937, and Partridge later wrote a whole monograph on the genre, The 'Shaggy Dog' Story: Its Origin, Development and Nature (1953). The technique is older than the name, though. Mark Twain's Roughing It (1872) has the story of "grandfather's old ram": a miner starts to tell it, wanders from one unrelated memory to the next and falls asleep before the ram ever does anything.

Anti-jokes: the short cousin

An anti-joke works on the same principle with less patience. It is set up like a joke, so you brace for a twist, and then the twist does not arrive. The humor is the surprise of a missing punchline. Some humor researchers treat the shaggy dog story as one type of anti-joke; in everyday use, "anti-joke" usually means the short kind.

Shaggy dog storyAnti-joke
LengthMinutesOne or two lines
What it subvertsThe idea that a long setup earns a big payoffThe idea that a punchline has a twist
Typical endingAnticlimax, bad pun, or the story just stopsThe most literal, obvious answer
Classic exampleThe dog that is "not so shaggy""Why did the chicken cross the road? To get to the other side."

The chicken joke is so familiar that people forget it is an anti-joke: the answer is simply true. The same goes for the "farmer" family of jokes: "What did the farmer say when he lost his tractor?" "Where's my tractor?"

A close relative is "No soap, radio," which is less a joke than a prank. The teller and an accomplice agree in advance to laugh at a meaningless punchline. The usual version has an elephant and a hippo in a bath; the elephant asks for the soap and the hippo answers, "No soap, radio." The accomplice roars with laughter, and the third person either pretends to get it or admits they don't. It became popular in New York in the 1950s and is often cited as a small demonstration of conformity and peer pressure.

Classic examples worth knowing

  • Mark Twain, "grandfather's old ram" (Roughing It, 1872). The narrator never learns what happened to the ram.
  • Arlo Guthrie, "Alice's Restaurant Massacree." A long talking song about the military draft that spends most of its running time on a littering arrest.
  • "Weird Al" Yankovic, "Albuquerque" (1999). More than eleven minutes of digressions that begin and end with the narrator's dislike of sauerkraut.
  • Norm Macdonald's moth joke. A short gag stretched into a bleak Russian-novel monologue about a moth visiting a podiatrist, all for a one-line ending.
  • Myles na gCopaleen's Keats and Chapman stories. Elaborate anecdotes in his Irish Times column, each built backwards from a painful pun.
  • "You're not a monk." A campfire story about a man who spends years earning the right to learn a monastery's secret. The teller then refuses to reveal it, because the listener is not a monk.

The Russian entry: the klyukalo joke

Russian has a strong tradition of long jokes told for the pleasure of the telling, and one of the best loved fits the shaggy dog pattern almost exactly. It circulates as "the klyukalo joke"; a version on the joke archive anekdot.ru appeared in an issue dated December 2004, in the section for repeats, so it was already an old one by then. Details change with the teller, but the story goes like this.

New conscripts line up at an army base. A warrant officer asks each man what he did in civilian life so he can put them to work: the bricklayer builds a wall, the painter paints a fence. The last recruit says he was a klyukalshchik, a klyukalo-maker. Nobody has heard of the trade, and he says a klyukalo is easier to make than to explain. He is given a workshop, sheet metal and three days. On the fourth day he comes out with a battered, crumpled lump of metal. The furious officer has him locked up and tosses the thing in a corner.

Later a general arrives on inspection, notices the object and lights up: someone here can make a klyukalo? He sends for the craftsman, and they take it to a lake to test it. The general throws it into the water. It sinks with one sound: "klyuk." The general sighs with pleasure at how beautifully it went.

That is the whole punchline. "Klyuk" (roughly "klyook") is just Russian for the noise a heavy object makes dropping into water, about what English speakers would write as "plop" or "bloop." The word "klyukalo" is invented. It is built to sound like the name of a real tool, and it turns out to mean "the thing that goes klyuk." Three days of hammering exist to justify one syllable.

Why does an anticlimax get a laugh?

Nobody has a complete theory, but the mechanics are easy to see. A joke normally works by setting up an expectation and then resolving it in a surprising way. A shaggy dog story sets up the biggest expectation it can and declines to resolve it, so the surprise is the absence of a surprise. The target of the joke shifts from the characters to the listener, who has been caught wanting a payoff.

There is also the performance. Much of the pleasure is watching someone commit to pointless detail with total seriousness, which is why these jokes survive best out loud, at campfires, on talk shows and in songs, and why the same story can be hilarious from one teller and unbearable from another.

How to tell one without losing the room

  1. Pick your audience. People who like being in on a bit will love it. People in a hurry will not.
  2. Never signal that it is a joke about nothing. Tell it as though the ending is worth waiting for.
  3. Make the details vivid, not just long. Each detour should be entertaining on its own; length alone is only a delay.
  4. Slow down before the ending. A pause makes the anticlimax land harder.
  5. Stop talking. Do not explain it. The groan is the applause.

A punchline you can keep in your pocket

The klyukalo joke depends on how well the teller can perform one wet, hollow syllable, and that is the reason iKlyukalo exists. It is a free joke app for iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch with two buttons, Klyuk and Long Klyuk, and a counter that keeps track of how many times you have klyuked this week. Tell the story, pause at the lake and let the phone deliver the ending.

Frequently asked questions

Why is it called a shaggy dog story?

The name comes from a long joke about a remarkably shaggy dog that ends with someone remarking the dog is not so shaggy after all. Several versions exist and authorities disagree on which is the original. The term is first recorded in Esquire in May 1937.

What is the difference between a shaggy dog story and an anti-joke?

Mostly length. A shaggy dog story takes minutes and ends in an anticlimax; an anti-joke is usually a line or two with a literal answer instead of a twist. Some humor researchers classify the shaggy dog story as a type of anti-joke.

What does "No soap, radio" mean?

Nothing, and that is the point. It is the nonsense punchline of a prank in which the teller and an accomplice laugh as if the joke made sense, to see whether a third person will pretend to get it. It became popular in New York in the 1950s.

What is a klyukalo?

An invented object from a Russian army joke. A recruit spends three days making a mysterious "klyukalo" out of sheet metal, and when a general throws it into a lake it sinks with the sound "klyuk," roughly "plop." The word means nothing beyond that sound.

Is "Why did the chicken cross the road?" an anti-joke?

Yes. The listener expects a clever twist and gets a plain statement of fact: to get to the other side. It is one of the standard examples of the obvious-punchline type of anti-humor.

Sources

  1. Shaggy dog story — Wikipedia
  2. Shaggy dog story — World Wide Words
  3. Anti-humor — Wikipedia
  4. No soap radio — Wikipedia
  5. Joke no. 132612 (the klyukalo joke, in Russian) — anekdot.ru